California Governor Newsom Blamed for Reparations Bill Failure

By: Julia Mehalko | Published: Sep 01, 2024

Activists and lawmakers are blaming California Governor Gavin Newsom for stalling slavery reparations bills on the state’s final day of the legislative session.

For years now, Newsom has publicly backed bills that would give reparations to the families of those affected by slavery. However, now it appears the governor has walked back this support somewhat.

Major Changes to the Reparations Bill

According to California lawmakers, the reparations bill’s initial draft included various aspects that were designed to help eventually form a system that allowed for reparations, or money, to be given to affected Californians.

Advertisement
An exterior view of the California State Capitol building.

Source: Josh Hild/Unsplash

Now, these lawmakers are explaining that the bill was changed at the last minute — and all because of Newsom.

Advertisement

Narrowing the Proposal

Newsom’s aides reportedly pushed to narrow this bill. As a result, the bill authorizes the study of reparations — and not much else.

Advertisement
A view of an American flag next to a California flag.

Source: Lesli Whitecotton/Pexels

According to a draft of the bill, the proposal suggests sending $6 million to California State University to study how to implement reparations policies.

Getting Rid of the Bill’s Core Issue

Because of these changes made, the bill’s initial core purpose has been completely removed.

Advertisement
A close-up of the exterior of the California Capitol.

Source: Kyle Smith/Unsplash

The bill was initially designed to create the formation of a new Freedmen Affairs Agency, which would begin finding the best way to create a reparations program in the state. Now, this agency’s formation is removed from the bill.

Lawmakers Point to Newsom

Many activists — including those who have long fought for and supported this bill — were stunned by these last-minute changes.

Advertisement
A close-up of Gavin Newsom.

Source: Bureau of Reclamation/Wikimedia Commons

Various lawmakers, most notably Democratic State Senator Steven Bradford, have blamed Newsom for this narrowing of the bill.

Why Newsom Made These Changes

Bradford told reporters that the bill’s new draft came from the governor’s office.

A California flag on a pole next to an American flag.

Source: Drei Kubik/Unsplash

These key changes were apparently made because of cost pressures seen during this year. Newsom has had to work with various lawmakers to ensure that billions were trimmed from this year’s budget. It now appears that the reparations bill is one issue that has been trimmed.

Advertisement

Newsom’s Response

While Newsom’s office wouldn’t answer any questions about the changes this bill has seen, spokesperson Izzy Gardon said that Newsom has “been working collaboratively with the Legislative Black Caucus on their reparations package.”

A view of the California Capitol seen in the distance behind tall buildings.

Source: Josh Hild/Unsplash

The governor’s office also pointed reporters to a statement Newsom gave back in January during budget talks.

Advertisement

Refusing the Governor’s Amendments

Bradford has revealed that he refused to accept Newsom’s amendments to this reparations bill.

Steven Bradford waving outside.

Source: mark6mauno/Wikimedia Commons

The state senator also said that he worried that the California Legislative Black Caucus felt they had to shelve these bills, and he disagreed with their decision to “only hold them now because of the possible concerns that have been expressed by the administration.”

Advertisement

Wanting to Move Forward

Bradford stated that while challenges may have been issued against these bills, they still should have moved forward.

A close-up of the California State Capitol dome seen at night.

Source: Tom Schönmann/Pexels

“You hear challenges on every piece of legislation,” Bradford said. “That doesn’t mean that you don’t move forward with it.”

Advertisement

Denials Are Issued

Meanwhile, Caucus chair Lori Wilson has admitted that the governor’s administration wanted changes done to the bill.

A portrait of Lori Wilson.

Source: Public Domain/Wikimedia Commons

However, Wilson also denied that Newsom tried to completely change a bill about creating a new agency into something else entirely. She denies this happened.

Advertisement

Backing Newsom

As many people, even former Newsom allies, have turned against the governor on this issue, Wilson has backed him.

Gavin Newsom speaking.

Source: Public Domain/Wikimedia Commons

“That is not true,” she said. “It’s unfortunate that that information was put out there. There was no way, shape or form that the Newsom administration recommended further study.”

Advertisement

California’s Reparations Bills

Various reparations bills have already been passed by the Legislature this year in California.

An exterior view of the California State Capitol building.

Source: W K/Unsplash

One bill includes forming a process to help Californians who had their land stolen from them through eminent domain in the past. Meanwhile, another requires California to formally apologize for discrimination, racism, and slavery.

Advertisement