California Parents Denounce Newsom’s Attempt to Help Struggling Students, Saying the ‘Damage Is Done’

By: Julia Mehalko | Published: Jul 16, 2024

California parents and school board officials have denounced Governor Gavin Newsom’s attempt to help struggling students who have suffered from learning loss as a result of school closures during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Newsom has approved a $2 billion aid package that will be dedicated to helping these students who have learning loss. However, many parents have claimed that the “damage is done.”

School Closures During the Pandemic

In the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, many states around the country shut down their schools in an attempt to stop the spread of the contagious virus.

Advertisement
A view of an empty classroom with many desks and chairs.

Source: MChe Lee/Unsplash

During this time, even Republican-led states held off on sending their students back to school. However, eventually, many states quickly reopened their schools, allowing their students to return to class.

Advertisement

California’s Schools Remained Closed

California differed from other states, as they had one of the first — and one of the strictest — state lockdowns seen during the pandemic.

Advertisement
A child wearing a mask sitting down outside on the steps of a school with his backpack.

Source: Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

This strict lockdown attempted to stop the very quick and deadly spread of the virus that California was trying to deal with. As a result, schools remained closed.

Virtual Learning

Instead of allowing students to return to class during this time, California pushed for virtual learning at home. Therefore, students had to go to school through video chats, like Zoom.

Advertisement
A young girl in front of a laptop during remote learning.

Source: Giovanni Gagliardi/Unsplash

All ages of students had to learn how to adapt to this new virtual learning process. Many parents and school board officials criticized this move at the time. Others supported it, mainly because of the ongoing pandemic.

Learning Loss

Unfortunately, many studies have since learned that students throughout the nation have suffered from what is being called “learning loss.”

Advertisement
A pile of books on a table.

Source: Alexander Grey/Unsplash

Because of these school closures seen during the pandemic, many students didn’t accurately learn vital lessons. Now, they are behind in school.

California Approves $2 Billion for Students

Now, Newsom has set aside $2 billion for students who have suffered from this learning loss — many of whom are low-income or minority students.

A close-up of crayons with a child coloring in the background.

Source: Aaron Burden/Unsplash

This money will go to tutoring and other services dedicated to helping students who have fallen behind because of the school closures seen during the pandemic.

Advertisement

A Settlement

This aid to students comes after California settled its Cayla J. v. California case earlier this year. This suit, which was first filed in November 2020, blamed the state for failing to help students during school closures.

A student sitting in class next to others with the teacher at the front.

Source: Taylor Flowe/Unsplash

The suit further insinuated that California didn’t accurately help parents and students during the time when school was virtual — and when students had to use digital devices to attend class.

Advertisement

The Damage Is Done

Though Newsom seemingly is admitting fault by approving these billions of dollars to help students, many parents and school board officials aren’t happy.

Many young students sitting down on the floor in a classroom.

Source: CDC/Unsplash

Sonia Shaw, the Chino Valley Unified School District Board President, recently said, “Unfortunately, the damage is done, and this should have been a priority to the Department of Education and the Governor. I’m grateful to those who never gave up to ensure resources are used to help students.”

Advertisement

Attacking Teachers’ Unions

Some parents didn’t just go after Newsom. They also went after California’s teachers’ unions.

A teacher standing at the front of the class with a student.

Source: Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels

Lance Christensen, a father of California students, said, “It’s time for the legislature to cut its ties with teachers’ unions who regularly rebuff any opportunities for educational reform.”

Advertisement

Parents Face Growing Frustration

Some parents also voiced their frustration over the fact that they feel they don’t have any resources to help their children in school.

Many students sitting down in a classroom looking at a teacher.

Source: Kenny Eliason/Unsplash

“Parents who have no real resources or options for their children in poor-performing public schools will see funds go to bureaucrats rather than programs they know will benefit their children,” Christensen added.

Advertisement

Newsom and Accountability

Christensen further stated that, even though Newsom has approved $2 billion to go to these students affected by school closures, Newsom still isn’t facing real accountability.

Gavin Newsom wearing a suit while smiling.

Source: Bureau of Reclamation/Wikimedia Commons

He said, “Rather than acknowledge how our state’s elected officials have consistently failed millions of children in our public schools, the legislature passed and the governor signed a bill that will not only send more money into our sub-par government schools, but have no real accountability other than reports that no one will read or seriously consider.”

Advertisement

Learning Loss Throughout America

Since the pandemic, many studies have been done on students who have suffered from learning loss.

A student walking through a classroom near other students sitting down.

Source: javier trueba/Unsplash

A recent Harvard study found that this learning gap hasn’t closed since school reopened. In the years since, this gap has only widened — allowing students to fall even further behind in school.

Advertisement