“Things Are Going to Get Ugly”: Trump’s Claims About Haitian Americans Spark Fear for Their Safety

By: David Donovan | Published: Sep 12, 2024

After Donald Trump repeated a false and derogatory claim about immigrants during this week’s presidential debate in Ohio, Haitian Americans stated that they are concerned for their safety.

Haitian community leaders across the U.S. said the former president’s comments regarding immigrants eating family pets during his discussion with Democrat VP Kamala Harris could seriously jeopardize people’s safety. 

Fanning the Flames

There are concerns that Trump’s remarks will fan the tensions in the small city of Springfield, Ohio, where huge number of new Haitian arrivals have supported the local economy yet additionally put a strain on the safety net.

Advertisement
Skyline view of downtown Springfield, the sun is setting as shadows are cast, the buildings are interspersed with trees and cars in parking lots.

Source: Rob Hat/springfieldohio.gov

“We have to be careful where we go,” said Viles Dorsainvil, 38, to Reuters, who says the Haitian community center he leads in Springfield has been plagued by threatening phone calls. The aggression has provoked one friend working at an Amazon distribution center to consider leaving, he said.

Advertisement

“Making Bad Comments About Us”

Dorsainvil went on to say, “He said that things are getting out of hand now; the way people are treating us, making bad comments about us.”

Advertisement
AB Graham and the first 4-H club, the statue shows two children and a man standing over them in a courtyard with trees and another structure.

Source: Cindy Funk/Flickr

Trump’s comment “they’re eating the dogs, the people that came in, they’re eating the cats” is the most recent in a long line of lies about migrants that have characterized his political profession. 

“Crimes of Opportunity”

It followed a comparable bogus claim spread by his running mate, U.S. Senator JD Vance of Ohio, via social media about Springfield’s new occupants.

Advertisement
J.D. Vance speaking at the 2024 People's Convention, he speaks into a mic as he gestures with his arm.

Source: Gage Skidmore/Flickr

According to city officials, there are no credible reports of people consuming domestic animals. Karen Graves, a city representative, said she didn’t know about recent hate crimes aimed at Haitian inhabitants but that some had been casualties of “crimes of opportunity,” like property theft.

Strained Resources

Haitian families in Springfield, Ohio, were preventing their children from going to school, and some were the subject of bullying, assaults, and intimidation at their homes after social media amplified these derogatory comments according to the Haitian Times.

Advertisement
Westcott House by Frank Lloyd Wright in Springfield, Ohio. There are plants and trees in front of the house.

Source: Niagara66/Wikimedia Commons

The lie benefited from the dissatisfactions of some in the western Ohio city, who say the 15,000 Haitians who have shown up lately to fuel the city’s economy, have likewise put a strain on the limited resources at nearby schools and hospitals and increased rents.

“People Are Getting Really Fed Up”

The community has faced tension with locals since a Haitian driver without an Ohio license struck a school bus in 2023, killing 11-year-old Aiden Clark and harming 26 other kids.

South Fountain Avenue Historic District, the old buildings have trees in front of them as well as plants, a car is parked on the street in front of one of the houses.

Source: Nyttend/Wikimedia Commons

At a city council meeting on Tuesday resident Richard Jordan said, “People are getting really fed up. Things are going to get ugly.”

Advertisement

“Fluffy Pets Being Ravaged”

Clark’s dad Nathan Clark condemned Trump and Vance for taking advantage of his child’s death at the same city council meeting.

Wittenberg University, the sign is in front of some gates, the buildings in the background are obscured by dead trees and cars on a road.

Source: Springfieldohio/Wikipedia

Clark stated, “They can vomit all the hate they want about illegal immigrants, the border crisis, and even untrue claims about fluffy pets being ravaged and eaten by community members. However, they are not allowed, nor have they ever been allowed, to mention Aiden Clark from Springfield, Ohio.”

Advertisement

Quell the Rumor

A white supremacist who had made threats to Haitian immigrants was kicked out of a meeting of the city council last month.

Vice President Mike Pence and Mrs. Karen Pence arrive at Neil Armstrong Operations and Checkout Facility in Merritt Island, Fla. Wednesday, May 27, 2020, and are greeted by Jim Bridenstine, NASA Administrator. Elon Musk, Founder and CEO

Source: The White House/Flickr

Prior to the debate, billionaire Elon Musk further spread the claim on his X social media platform, as did conservatives on the House of Representatives Judiciary Committee. Guerline Jozef, who chairs the national advocacy group Haitian Bridge Alliance, said her organization had been attempting to quell the rumor before Harris and Trump faced off.

Advertisement

“A Nationwide Lie”

At the point when Trump referenced the rumor, Jozef said “my heart fell to the floor. This has become a nationwide lie that people everywhere are repeating.”

Guerline Jozef speaking into a mic on stage on a stool alongside three other people.

Source: GuerlineMJozef/X

Taisha Saintil, presently an analyst with the immigrant advocacy group UndocuBlack Network, said Trump’s comment brought back difficult recollections of being provoked when she showed up at a Florida primary school in 2006.

Advertisement

Moving States

1.1 million Haitian Americans live in the U.S., about half of whom are immigrants, as per the Census Bureau. Long settled in Florida and New York, Haitian immigrants have as of late been moving to states like North Carolina and California to seek work, Jozef said.

Springfield News-Sun former headquarters, the building is on the corner of two streets and is a new classical style with a short balcony on the second floor and trees in front of it.

Source: Cindy Funk/Flickr

Springfield authorities say most Haitian migrants are in the nation lawfully, drawn by occupations at distribution centers and plants. According to a city fact sheet, they have opened two restaurants and seven grocery stores.

Advertisement

“Challenges Related to Rapid Growth”

In a video posted on Wednesday, city manager Bryan Heck stated, “While we are experiencing challenges related to the rapid growth of our immigrant population, these challenges are primarily due to the pace of the growth.”

Mike DeWine speaking at a lectern into a mic as he motions with his hand, there are three people standing to the side slightly blurred.

Source: The United States Department of Justice/justice.gov

Ohio Governor Republican Mike DeWine, said on Tuesday the state is giving $2.5 million to assist the new occupants with getting vaccines and accessing other health services, and state police are being enlisted in order to aid in enforcing traffic laws. 

Advertisement

Seeking Help

DeWine said President Joe Biden’s administration ought to likewise give help to cities like Springfield that see an unexpected expansion in new immigrants.

Mike DeWine greeting President Donald Trump in 2019, the two shake hands as other people stand by at the stairs coming from a plane on a runway.

Source: The White House/Flickr

Trump’s remarks could stimulate his allies to assist him with winning over unsure voters, especially frustrated white citizens who feel their very own sense of decline in this nation, said Republican strategist Mike Madrid, the man behind the anti-Trump Lincoln Project.

Madrid stated, “The attempts to dehumanize people is a long-proven strategy to work at a time when society’s undergoing change.”

Advertisement