Federal Court Upholds Overturning of Minnesota Gun Law, Quotes Second Amendment Age Limit

By: Alex Trent | Last updated: Aug 05, 2024

A new ruling from a federal appeals court on Tuesday determined that a Minnesota law that required someone to be 21 years old before they could obtain a handgun permit to use in public for self-defense is unconstitutional.

The ruling comes from the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, based in St. Louis.

Court Case

Gun rights groups including the Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus, the Second Amendment Foundation, and the Firearms Policy Coalition filed suit in court against the Minnesota permit-to-carry statute, challenging its age restrictions.

Advertisement
A close-up of a wooden judge’s gavel amid a black background.

Source: Tingey Injury Law Firm/Unsplash

The plaintiffs in the case alleged that the enforcement of the age limit violated the Second Amendment rights of 18-20-year-olds under the Constitution.

Advertisement

Judge’s Ruling

This latest ruling from the 8th District upheld a lower judge’s court ruling last year that found in favor of the gun rights groups.

Advertisement
A look up at an American flag on a pole underneath a blue sky.

Source: Kevin McCartney/Pexels

“Importantly, the Second Amendment’s plain text does not have an age limit,” wrote U.S. 8th Circuit Judge Duane Benton in the ruling.

Ruling Reasoning

Benton wrote in the decision that the state had not clearly established why the risk posed by 18 to 20-year-olds justified the restrictions on age set in the law.

Advertisement
A closeup view of a pistol

Source: Jay Rembert/Unsplash

“Minnesota has not met its burden to proffer sufficient evidence to rebut the presumption that 18 to 20-year-olds seeking to carry handguns in public for selfdefense are protected by the right to keep and bear arms. The Carry Ban, § 624.714 subd. 2(b)(2), violates the Second Amendment as applied to Minnesota through the Fourteenth Amendment, and, thus, is unconstitutional,” wrote Benton.

What the Second Amendment Says

The Second Amendment of the US Constitution makes it clear that a well-regulated Militia is necessary for the security of a free State.

Advertisement
A man holding a shotgun and pointing it towards the woods.

Sebastian Pociecha/Unsplash

It also states that it is within the rights of the people of the US to keep and bear arms and that this cannot be infringed.

What the Second Amendment Means

Many people get confused by the wording of the Second Amendment, as it can be somewhat confusing.

A black handgun against a camouflaged background.

Thomas Tucker/Unsplash

The Second Amendment essentially means that all Americans have the right to own and carry firearms to protect themselves against threats and that the government is unable to interfere with this right.

Advertisement

The Bruen Decision

When the court case was presented to US District Judge Katherine Menendez in March 2023, she struck the law down but granted an emergency motion for a stay, as requested by the state of Minnesota.

Katherine Menendez talking into a mic.

United States Judiciary Committee/Wikimedia Commons

This is an example of the 2022 Supreme Court case, the Bruen decision, which overturned nationwide gun laws. This decision divided courts and resulted in some confusion as to which restrictions could still remain in place.

Advertisement

What the Bruen Decision Established

The Bruen decision was a historic moment for gun laws across the US and was the most significant gun ruling in the high court for more than a decade.

A black gun pointing towards a field.

Thomas Tucker/Unsplash

It included the right for Americans to carry firearms in public for self-defense purposes and establishing a new test for evaluating challenges to gun restrictions. Courts now have to ask themselves whether any imposed restrictions are in keeping with the country’s historic firearm regulations.

Advertisement

Minnesota Law

The law overturned by this decision was passed in Minnesota in 2003. The law raised restrictions to only allow individuals age 21 and over to carry a handgun in public for self-defense.

The capital building in Minnesota.

Source: Northfielder/Wikimedia

The federal age limit for this right is 18 years old.

Advertisement

20th Century Laws

In defense of the 2003 law, the state tried to present a 20th-century law precedent that bans firearm carry by “the mentally ill or those with unsound minds.” However, Benton disagreed that just being a certain age meant that one is comparable to being mentally ill.

Two handguns are placed side by side on a white surface, with their barrels pointing to the left

Source: maxx/Unsplash

“Those laws, still in effect, prevent the mentally ill from acquiring firearms. Minnesota may not claim all 18 to 20-year-olds are comparable to the mentally ill. This court declines to read a new category into the list of presumptively lawful statutes,” Benton wrote.

Advertisement

Disappointment in the Decision

Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison has expressed his disappointment at the ruling and said that the state of Minnesota is still trying to decide how to proceed.

A black handgun lying in the grass.

Jens Lelie/Unsplash

He also made it clear how troubling the ruling is, especially as it came just a few days after a 20-year-old fired shots at former President Donald Trump during a rally in Pennsylvania.

Advertisement

A Need for Safety

Most residents of any area, whether in the US or elsewhere in the world, will agree that their safety is of paramount importance and shouldn’t be compromised.

A man in protective gear holding a black gun in a field.

Specna Arms/Unsplash

Many people in the US want an increase in safety, which they believe can only happen by imposing restrictions on guns.

Advertisement

Republican Appointees

Benton wrote the opinion for a panel of three judges that made the ruling in the case that sided with the plaintiffs.

The logo for the Republican Party in the United States.

Source: Republican Party/Wikimedia

All three judges have been appointed by Republican presidents and determined that recent Supreme Court rulings have expanded gun rights to the point that the Minnesota law can no longer stand.

Advertisement

Republicans, Democrats, and Gun Laws

Republicans and Democrats might differ on many things, but there are some areas of gun laws that people supporting the two parties can relatively agree on.

A man in camouflage holding a gun while hiding behind a brick wall.

Specna Arms/Unsplash

Both Republicans and Democrats strongly believe that there should be background checks on people purchasing guns, people with mental illnesses should be prevented from purchasing guns, and family members should be able to go to court if they are worried that a gun owner might harm themselves or others.

Advertisement

Differences in Republicans and Democrats

Despite there being very few similarities between Democrats and Republicans, there are a lot of differences in opinion when it comes to gun laws. One of which is Democrats being strongly in favor of banning assault-style weapons, whereas Republicans tend to be strongly against this.

A black gun with a gold bullet inside it.

Thomas Tucker/Unsplash

There are also differences when it comes to schools, with Democrats being against teachers and school officials carrying guns in K-12 schools, whereas Republicans are in favor of this. Republicans also tend to believe that the right to own a gun is more important than protecting people from gun violence, whereas Democrats are completely against this.

Advertisement

Supreme Court Ruling

In his ruling, Judge Benton cited a 2022 Supreme Court Case that struck down a New York gun law and established a right for an individual to carry a handgun in public for self-defense.

A view of the U.S. Supreme Court building seen in the daytime.

Source: Joshua Woods/Unsplash

The opinion in the case, authored by Justice Clarence Thomas, asserted that the US Constitution establishes “an individual’s right to carry a handgun for self-defense outside the home.”

Advertisement

Celebrating the Decision

The Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus took to the social media platform X to celebrate their win in the latest court ruling.

A grouping of balloons floating on the ceiling.

Source: Adi Goldstein/Unsplash

“Good morning all, This week we kicked Keith Ellison’s *ss at the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals,” the group wrote. Keith Ellison is the Attorney General for Minnesota and has defended the 2003 law.

Advertisement

Plotting to Sue More

Not content to rest on the laurels of victory, the Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus promised that more lawsuits would come in the future to protect the gun rights of Minnesotans.

Close-up of a lawsuit document with a gavel placed on top, on a wooden desk with a pen lying beside the paper

Source: wirestock/freepik

“We’re already plotting who we should sue next as we work to take down the disarmament regime here in Minnesota – and we’re aiming to put a Pro-2A legislature in the Minnesota House,” wrote the group on X.

Advertisement

Declaring Victory

The Second Amendment Foundation (SAF) was also in a celebratory mood following the 8th Circuit’s decision, framing the ruling as a win for young adults.

A Glock pistol holstered in a black and pink stitched leather holster with a decorative cross pattern

Source: seeetz/Unsplash

“Today the Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed the district court’s opinion which struck down Minnesota’s ban on carry for young adults as unconstitutional,” said an X post by the group.

Advertisement

Gun Lawsuits in the US

There have been several gun lawsuits across the US in recent years, with those involved either trying to overturn gun laws in various states that have limited the use of guns in an ‘unconstitutional’ move or trying to impose stricter gun regulations.

A black shotgun against a yellow background.

Scott Szarapka/Unsplash

Another case involved Mexico, which was able to win a $10 billion lawsuit against US gunmakers, as guns being made in the US were ending up in the hands of cartels.

Advertisement

Age Restrictions on Gun Laws

Minnesota isn’t the only state that wants to raise the age limit for people able to purchase firearms, as other states have previously done the same thing, often with the same outcome.

A black handgun in a brown leather holster.

seeetz/Unsplash

Georgia, Illinois, and Pennsylvania are all examples of states that have tried to impose laws on age groups able to purchase firearms. Still, the Constitution and courts have always remained strong in their stance.

Advertisement

Supreme Court Overhauling the Second Amendment

The situation with gun laws has got to the point where the Supreme Court is planning on completely rewriting the Second Amendment.

The outside of the Supreme Court building.

Fine Photographics/Unsplash

However, this isn’t good news for campaigners for gun safety. There is the belief that should this happen, it will be challenging to regulate guns or keep schools and communities safe, especially when it is already pretty hard to do this.

Advertisement

The Proposed 28th Amendment

However, not everyone supports these laws and wants to tackle gun violence. One of these people is Gavin Newsom, Governor of California.

Two men in camouflage holding black shotguns.

Daniel/Unsplash

He has proposed a 28th Amendment to the US Constitution that would ban people under 21 from buying firearms, ban assault weapons, and mandate universal background checks. However, with this recent decision in Minnesota, there is doubt over whether this will happen.

Advertisement

Constitutional Rights

The group’s post continued, affirming their commitment to protecting the Second Amendment rights of young adults.

A view through a magnifying glass of the Constitution.

Source: Anthony Garand/Unsplash

“It is encouraging that yet another circuit court has correctly concluded that 18-20-year-olds are part of ‘the People’ to which the Second Amendment extends. SAF remains steadfast in its commitment to ensure that young adults are able to fully exercise their constitutional right to keep and bear arms,” said the SAF post.

Advertisement