Florida Housing Market Faces ‘Nightmare’ Scenario

By: Julia Mehalko | Last updated: Aug 09, 2024

Real estate agents in Florida are sounding the alarm about the Sunshine State’s ongoing housing market issues, as many now believe they are facing a “nightmare” scenario.

New data has indicated that many Florida homebuyers are canceling their deals to purchase homes at a new record rate, which has complicated the housing market in the state.

Housing Cancellations Soar

A new report from Redfin, a real estate brokerage, has revealed that home purchase agreement cancellations have soared at a new record rate.

Advertisement
People shaking hands and holding out a house key.

Source: RDNE Stock project/Pexels

According to this report, almost 56,000 agreements were canceled in just June alone in Florida. This was about 14.9% of all the homes that were under contract in June. It’s also the highest percentage ever recorded for the month.

Advertisement

Some Florida Cities Have Been Hit Hard

Some cities in Florida are seeing these record cancellations more than others. For example, Miami has seen a large amount of last-minute cancellations as homebuyers think twice about purchasing property in the area.

Advertisement
An aerial view of Miami on the coast.

Source: Ashley Satanosky/Unsplash

Redfin data has revealed that about 2,500 home purchases were canceled in Miami in June, which was about 17.6% of all the homes that were under contract in the city at the time.

A Nightmare Scenario

These situations have resulted in Florida real estate agents sounding the alarm. Rafael Corrales, a Miami Redfin Premier agent, further opened up about this.

Advertisement
A view of a blue home in Florida.

Source: Debby Hudson/Unsplash

“We’re seeing nightmare scenarios where deals are getting canceled at the last minute for the most minute reasons,” Corrales said.

Why Are Buyers Backing Out?

Agents have revealed that there are a variety of reasons why homebuyers may be backing out of buying a home that they previously wanted. However, one factor rises above all the rest: affordability.

Advertisement
A person holding out a house key.

Source: Kindel Media/Pexels

Corrales explained, “Buyers often back out during the inspection period because they find something they don’t like, but affordability is really the underlying issue.”

Orlando Had the Highest Home Purchase Agreements Cancelled

Orlando is reported to have the most buyers backing out of a house sale last minute, at 20.8%.

A house in Orlando with a palm tree outside.

Source: Eric Artido/Unsplash

Then it was Jacksonville (20.5%), Tampa (20.5%), Las Vegas (20.2%) and San Antonio (19.9%).

Advertisement

Surprise Expenses

Many potential homebuyers may not be considering the extra expenses that come with owning a home, such as taxes and HOA fees.

A view of a home and porch in Florida.

Source: Sean Foster/Unsplash

Corrales added, “I don’t want my buyers to be surprised by all of the expenses that come with owning a home in Florida, so I advise them to proactively research the hefty costs of insurance, property taxes and HOA fees, in addition to the cost of their mortgage payment.”

Advertisement

Florida Home Insurance Is High

One of Florida’s many issues regarding the housing market is the price of home insurance. This is partly due to the weather conditions in the Sunshine State, such as hurricanes, which cause premiums to rise.

A house in Florida on the water.

Source: Lo Sarno/Unsplash

As people who have lived in Florida their whole lives or who moved here hoping to find somewhere cheaper to live are being priced out of their own homes, this is forcing many residents to sleep elsewhere, either out of state or in their cars.

Advertisement

Investors Warn About Home Insurance

The home insurance crisis in Florida has become so bad that real estate investors warned people at the beginning of 2024 that home insurance prices would skyrocket.

An aerial view of some houses on the beach in Florida next to the sea.

Source: Asael Peña/Unsplash

Regardless of whether anyone decided to pay attention to them, the investors turned out to be correct.

Advertisement

Borrowing Costs Are High

Another issue is that potential buyers’ borrowing costs continue to remain high, which makes them want to reconsider buying a house in Florida.

A house in Florida next to some large trees and a body of water.

Source: Miguel Joya/Unsplash

However, the 30-year fixed mortgage rate remains steady at 6.7%, which might give potential buyers peace of mind.

Advertisement

Californians and New Yorkers Moving to Florida

Prior to home insurance and house prices skyrocketing, Florida was considered one of the cheaper places to live so much so that Californians and New Yorkers flocked there.

The U.S. flag hanging outside a house.

Source: Debby Hudson/Unsplash

The number of people choosing to move to Florida, which meant its population hit more than 23 million for the first time in history, also made the housing market more competitive.

Advertisement

Florida Cost of Living

For anyone considering moving to Florida or currently living there, it is always important to know the average cost of living in the state so that people know how much they can expect to spend in a regular month.

A house in Florida surrounded by greenery.

Source: Joshua Case/Unsplash

For a family of four living in Orlando, it costs an average of $4,180 a month without rent, whereas it costs $1,170 a month for a single person without rent.

Advertisement

How Much Do You Need to Earn to Live in Florida?

It’s also important to be aware of the average annual salary you will need to earn to live in Florida, whether you are a single person or a group of people combining their incomes.

A black and white image of $100 notes fanned out.

Source: Pepi Stojanovski/Unsplash

On average, you would need to earn around $77,000 annually to be able to live in Florida. Any lower, and you will struggle in one way or another. However, this all depends on your area and how many people have to live off your income.

Advertisement

Miami Beach Is the Most Expensive Area

$77,000 is the lowest income you will need to live in Florida, and this is for Daytona Beach. However, the most expensive place to live in is Miami Beach.

A sign for Miami Beach on a hut with the beach and sea right next to it. People are sunbathing and walking on the beach.

Source: Marc Fanelli-Isla/Unsplash

The average home value there is $2.3 million, and the average mortgage payment is $13,836. This means that the average annual income needed to live in Miami Beach is over $377,000.

Advertisement

Florida’s Expensive Housing Market

However, Corrales explained that most people back out of buying a home because it has become too expensive. Owning a home in Florida has become unaffordable for many.

An aerial of many homes near water in Florida.

Source: Luiz Cent/Unsplash

Housing prices have soared in the Sunshine State in the past few years. Adding other expenses, such as taxes, onto a property has further pushed out many potential homebuyers.

Advertisement

Florida Home Prices Continue to Skyrocket

Redfin data has previously revealed that the median sale price of a home in Florida was $442,525 in June of 2024. This is up about 0.9% from the previous month.

A view of a white home with a porch in Florida.

Source: Eric Ardito/Unsplash

However, it’s also up 4% year over year. This median sale price is even higher than the peak seen in 2022 during the pandemic, which only rose to $410,000.

Advertisement

Why Florida Homes Keep Rising in Price

There are a variety of reasons why homes continue to soar in price in Florida. However, the ongoing housing crisis in the state hasn’t helped at all.

An aerial view of Florida homes near the water.

Source: Chris Norberg/Unsplash

Simply, there aren’t enough homes to go around. There isn’t enough inventory for buyers. Though Florida is in a better position with its housing market than other states, it’s still struggling.

Advertisement

The Surfside Condo Collapse

Another issue people are having with buying and selling their homes in Florida is due to the Surfside condo collapse in 2021.

The Surfside condo collapse. Part of the building is still standing, but the rest is on the ground.

Source: Miami-Dade Fire Rescue Department/Wikimedia Commons

This brought new laws into the state, including that older condo buildings must maintain reserve funds and undergo structural inspections. Buyers also have to read through the HOA board meeting minutes, and some are hiring lawyers because sellers refuse to share the necessary information.

Advertisement

Loan-Assistance Programs

Due to the income needed to live in Florida and the high house prices and mortgage rates, those on lower incomes are questioning how they can continue to live in or buy a house in the Sunshine State.

A person sitting on the floor with $100 notes fanned out.

Source: Alexander Mils/Unsplash

This is possible through various programs, such as loan and assistance programs given by housing finance agencies and mortgage lenders, to make homeownership more affordable.

Advertisement

Some Florida House Prices Are Coming Down

While some house prices seem to be skyrocketing throughout Florida, there are other areas where house prices are slowly dropping.

An aerial view of a house in Florida with a swimming pool and jetty. It is next to the water.

Source: Derek Thomson/Unsplash

This is mainly in the Sun Belt due to supply outpacing demand, which is also happening in Texas.

Advertisement

A Shift in Housing Market Dynamics

The fact that there is evidence of house prices going down in the Sun Belt suggests that there might be a significant shift in housing market dynamics in the future.

Houses in Florida next to the sea with palm trees inside.

Source: Joseph Kellner/Unsplash

It is predicted that some house prices along this strip could fall by as much as 15%, which would then cause a whole different kind of nightmare.

Advertisement

Americans Are Flocking to Florida

Over the past few years, many Americans have flocked to Florida, choosing to find a home in the Sunshine State for a more affordable price. This has resulted in the state’s population growing and hitting a new milestone.

The silhouette of palm trees in Florida during sunset.

Source: Del Adams/Pexels

However, with more people now living in the state, more homes are also needed. Since there aren’t enough homes in some areas, this low demand has caused home prices to skyrocket.

Advertisement

Florida Is Building New Homes

Florida has been quickly building new homes throughout the state to deal with this shortage. It’s one of the only states in the country that has been building the most homes in the past few years.

A close-up of a key in a door.

Source: PhotoMIX Company/Pexels

However, this hasn’t seemed to help the housing market in the state yet. Experts have claimed that buyers still feel they don’t have enough options — and that homes are too expensive.

Advertisement

Buyers Aren’t Purchasing Homes

Because of all of these factors, homebuyers aren’t purchasing homes, even though many want to. It’s simply become too expensive for many.

A view of a yellow and red home in Florida.

Source: Julien Maculan/Unsplash

This has resulted in a record rate of people canceling contracts to buy a home, as well as forcing homes to stay on the market for a long time, making them “stale” listings.

Advertisement