MTA Demands NYC Marathon Organizers Pay $750,000 to Make Up Toll Revenue Loss During the Race

By: Stephanie Bontorin | Published: Apr 11, 2024

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) has threatened to restrict the traditional route of the New York City Marathon unless organizers pay up.

The marathon usually passes through both the upper and lower level of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge and must be shut down for almost an entire day while the race takes place.

Big Financial Hit For the MTA

Every year, photographers place themselves in the perfect position to get a shot of the classic New York bridge filled to the brim with runners beginning their 26.2 mile run.

Advertisement
Three young runners lead the pack on the Verrazzano Bridge during a marathon. Behind them, multiple runners can be seen as well as the architecture of the suspension bridge

Source: Wikipedia Commons

The transit authority says that each year they lose roughly $750,000 due to the bridge closure on the day of the race.

Advertisement

The Bridge Helps New York City Function

The Verrazzano-Narrows is North America’s longest suspension bridge.

Advertisement
A side view of a large suspension bridge positioned over a large body of water with green foliage on both sides

Source: Wikipedia Commons

Each day, roughly 200,000 cars cross the bridge that connects Brooklyn to Staten Island. Every vehicle that goes across the structure must pay a toll according to size and registration.

New York Road Runners Not Backing Down

The group that organizes the race every year, New York Road Runners, have refused to agree to the terms.

Advertisement
A man with his back to the camera holds his cellphone recording marathon runners. In the background, multiple people can be seen drenched in sweat and running. An american flag and an umbrella can also be seen in the background

Source: Spencer Imbrock/Unsplash

Since 1988 the marathon has used both the upper and lower decks of the bridge. But without payment, the MTA says that they cannot allow the race to continue as normal.

The New York City Marathon Brings in Big Bucks

More than 50,000 runners join the marathon every year from around the world. The race brings in roughly $427 million to the city boosted through tourism and tax revenue.

Advertisement
A low profile shot of the many billboards, yellow cabs, and people walking through Times Square

Source: Wallula/Pixabay

Alongside amateur runners, enthusiasts, professionals, the amount of media coverage that is brought to the city each year boosts a positive view of the city.

How the Closure Would Affect the Race

The MTA has offered the race organizers to use just one level of the bridge if they don’t want to pay the hefty fine.

A single person runs alongside the waterfront in New York City. Above him the Brooklyn bridge can be seen

Source: Ivan Karpov/Unsplash

However, officials say that the reduced space would limit the number of runners allowed to race or extend the duration. Both of these options would have a negative impact on the event.

Advertisement

The Bill Would Affect Other Free Running Events

The marathon is a fund-raised event and uses any additional cash to help organize free running events in the city.

The silhouette of three cyclists and their bikes as well as pedestrians sitting on benches are seen in the foreground. Behind them, the Brooklyn Bridge is shown in full view with water below and the view of the city can be seen further.

Source: Domo/Unsplash

The MTA has also taken aim at other events in the city that use the bridge as a traditional landmark. They requested reimbursement from Bike New York, a small group that uses the Verrazzano’s lower deck as their last leg on their Five Boro Bike Tour.

Advertisement

New York Governors Called In

Since the event organizers don’t think that the price tag is a fair use of fund-raised money, they have called on Gov. Kathy Hochul to mediate.

An upwards shot of a large suspension bridge complete with concrete pillars on a nice day

Source: Jason Krieger/Unsplash

Rob Simmelkjaer, the chief executive of the runner’s group, pleaded his case to Hochul, who controls the MTA and could easily assist with the issue.

Advertisement

New Yorker’s Are Not Put out on Race Day

Since the event has been a staple of New York life since the late 80s, most residents of the city happily work their lives around it.

A large group of runners packs a small street with green foliage on either side. The runners all wear bright colors and a number on their chest

Source: RUN 4 FFWPU/Pexels

Many locals even step out into the streets to show support to runners or apply to work as unpaid volunteers for the massive event.

Advertisement

MTA Messaging Unclear and Unfair

The transportation authority has stated that New York taxpayers shouldn’t be expected to foot the bill for the lost revenue.

A man wearing a blue suit jacket walks down the stairs of a subway station. Closer to the camera, green subway grates and a black subway sign are shown

Source: Wells Baum/Unsplash

However, race organizers have called out the inconsistent messaging. The diverted bridge traffic boosts subway fares for the day, which also goes directly to the MTA.

Advertisement

Millions of Riders Use the Subway on Race Day

The day after the 2023 marathon, the MTA reported a staggering 2,304,683 paid rides on the day of the race.

In the underground subway station a train car can be seen moving. In front of it, empty benches and pillars are seen

Source: Brad Bang/Unsplash

The boost in fares is directly related to the runners, volunteers, and supporters of the event as well as New Yorkers who took the subway instead of the Verrazzano Bridge.

Advertisement

MTA’s Logic Should Be Questioned

James Parrott, who works as the director of economic and fiscal policy at the New School’s Center for New York City Affairs has some harsh words for the transit authority.

A man wearing a dark green tank top runs while clutching his race number. Behind him, another runner wearing a blue tank top, black shorts, and a race number is seen along with orange pylons and race supporters

Source: Sebastian Enrique/Unsplash

He stated that it seems the MTA is attempting to “nickel-and-dime” the residents of NYC. The revenue from the rest of the year makes up for hundreds of millions of dollars and should be more than enough to cover the working costs of the transit authority.

Advertisement