Soaring Crime and Costs Lead to Closure of America’s Classic Diner

By: Georgia | Published: Sep 06, 2024

Denny’s isn’t just a diner — it’s an American staple.

Yet, recently, the beloved chain closed 15 more locations. Rising costs and fewer sales have forced Denny’s to downsize significantly, adding to the 57 locations closed last year and 60 in 2022. It’s a tough time for the iconic diner.

Fewer Americans Eating Out

It’s getting tougher out there. With prices going up for the last two years, fewer people are eating out. 

Advertisement
Interior of a Denny's diner featuring red leather booths, dark wood tables and modern hanging lights with yellow lampshades

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This trend has hit Denny’s hard, resulting in a noticeable drop in customers. As wallets tighten, the familiar sight of families at diner tables is becoming less common.

Advertisement

A Community Cornerstone Closes in Pennsylvania

June 19 was a sad day for Langthorne, Pennsylvania, as the town said goodbye to its last Denny’s. 

Advertisement
A table set with Denny's breakfast including pancakes topped with butter, eggs scrambled, crispy bacon strips and a side of hash browns and toast, reflecting a typical American breakfast.

Source: Denny’s/Facebook

This diner was more than a place to eat — it was a community hub for countless local stories and gatherings, now closed for good.

The Last in a County

San Francisco is not the only place that Denny’s has left completely.

Advertisement
A Denny's breakfast.

Source: The Real Ferny Duran/Facebook

After 45 years, the Langhorne Denny’s closed its doors. This branch was the last diner in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Now if people in Bucks County want to dine at Denny’s, they have to travel out to Lehigh Valley, Delaware County or even New Jersey.

Ohio Feels the Impact Too

Another Denny’s restaurant, located in Ashland, Ohio, was also closed last month. 

Advertisement
Classic Denny's restaurant exterior with a red tile roof and a large Denny's sign on the building, surrounded by green landscaping and a clear blue sky

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This follows the pattern of closures that has been affecting the diner chain, reflecting broader challenges within the restaurant industry that are leading to such difficult decisions.

Denny's Abandons California City

While other states have seen one or two Denny’s closures, a major California city has lost its last diner with the franchise.

San Francisco cityscape at dusk, showing modern skyscrapers and traditional houses under a soft orange sky

Source: Josh Hild/Unsplash

As of this month, the last Denny’s diner has closed in San Francisco. The diner was forced to close after 25 years of operating in the city’s Union Square district as a 24-hour restaurant.

Advertisement

Blaming the Customers

Chris Haque, the operator of the Denny’s, told the San Francisco Gate that the diner “operated until the last day that we could.”

A Denny's sign inside a shopping mall.

Source: Akinori Takemoto/Wikimedia Commons

Haque said the reason for the restaurant’s closure was crime. This San Francisco location was reportedly a hotspot for “dining and dashing,” where customers leave without paying the bill.

Advertisement

Struggles to Break Even

With the high costs of running a franchise, Haque said crime incurred even more costs on the business.

A Denny's sign.

Source: Andreas Praefcke/Wikimedia Commons

“The cost of doing business is tremendous. There’s vandalism, and people come and eat and walk away, and there’s no one to stop them. It’s a beautiful city we love it, we have been there so many years. But I think [city officials] should make it more business-friendly,” said Haque.

Advertisement

Declining Sales Despite Price Hikes

Despite nudging prices up, Denny’s has seen a 0.6% drop in same-store sales from last year. 

Close-up of a Denny's breakfast plate with pancakes, whipped butter, sunny-side-up eggs, hash browns and bacon, served on a red and white checkered tablecloth with a white Denny’s coffee mug

Source: Denny’s/Facebook

It’s a clear sign: fewer people are walking through the doors, and it’s hitting the bottom line hard.

Advertisement

Inflation Strikes

Robert Verostek, Denny’s CFO, explained in a February talk with investors that inflation was a major factor.

Contemporary design of a Denny’s restaurant featuring a red and yellow color scheme with geometric architectural elements and outdoor seating under red umbrellas, illustrating a modern twist on the classic diner

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The financial squeeze isn’t just numbers on a page — it’s fewer open diners and lost jobs.

Advertisement

Revenue Down

According to Denny’s report for the first quarter of this year, revenue has gone down.

A Denny's restaurant.

Source: JJBers/Wikimedia Commons

The franchise’s total operating revenue was $110 million between January and March. This sum is down from $117.5 million in the same quarter of last year. In the same period last year, Denny’s opened five new restaurants.

Advertisement

Higher Costs, Higher Stakes

Keeping a Denny’s open now costs more — $1.2 million up from $1 million. 

Illuminated Denny's sign at night with a dramatic dark sky and a colorful glow reflecting off the restaurant's roof

Source: Denny’s/Facebook

It’s a steep climb caused by rising food and labor costs. Every penny counts more than ever, as Verostek explained to investors.

Advertisement

Hit the Hardest in California

Restaurant chains have suffered the most in California.

A California state flag on a pole next to an American one.

Source: Drei Kubik/Unsplash

Since the new minimum wage for fast-food workers jumped to $20 per hour in April, labor costs have skyrocketed. Much like other restaurants, Denny’s has upped their prices to match expenses, which has led to a fall in the number of customers. Along with price hikes, many fast-food workers have consequently been let go.

Advertisement

Denny’s Bets on Value Menu

With a plan to win back customers, Denny’s is bringing back its $2-$4-$6-$8 value menu this summer. 

A table filled with various Denny's meals including a burger, fries, sandwiches, pancakes, eggs and drinks.

Source: Denny’s/Facebook

It’s a hopeful strategy aimed at making dining out affordable again.

Advertisement

CEO Believes in the Comeback

This was a value platform unique to Denny’s that launched years ago to amazing results, and it’s a unique equity only we have,” CEO Kelli Valade shared with investors. 

Kelli Valade speaking confidently at a conference, standing against a blue background with the word "INFLUENCE" prominently displayed

Source: Wikimedia Commons

It’s this unique appeal they’re banking on to turn the tide and draw diners back in.

Advertisement

Rethinking and Revamping

“We’re thrilled to bring back this consumer-friendly, traffic-driving platform based on extensive testing and reengineering,” Valade elaborated

Close-up headshot of a smiling woman with shoulder-length dark hair, wearing professional attire

Source: Wikimedia Commons

It’s not just about bringing back old favorites. It’s about adapting them to fit today’s diner’s needs and expectations.

Advertisement

Other Chains Are Shutting Locations

Other restaurant chains have closed their doors due to high costs and low customer numbers.

A Red Lobster restaurant.

Source: Mike Mozart/Wikimedia Commons

Red Lobster filed for bankruptcy in May, shutting down almost 100 restaurants. Even more chains like Applebee’s, TGI Fridays and Boston Market have also closed down.

Advertisement

Other Chains' Futures Are Uncertain

Other restaurant chains are likely to file for bankruptcy, even if it is not set in stone.

Mod Pizza with drink.

Source: Chris Cross/Facebook

Mod Pizza, a build-your-own pizza joint, shut down 26 locations during the first three months of this year. Despite being one of the fastest-growing chains in the country, Mod Pizza’s plans to set up more branches were dashed by closures and potential bankruptcy.

Advertisement

California Restaurants Going Under

Restaurant chains based in California are also suffering from high costs because they have nowhere else to go.

Rubio's signs against a blue sky.

Source: Rubio's Coastal Grill/X

In June this year, Rubio’s Coastal Grill closed 48 of its California locations and also filed for bankruptcy. “While painful, the store closures are a necessary step in our strategic long-term plan to position Rubio’s for success for years to come,” said a Rubio’s spokesperson.

Advertisement

Industry-Wide Shifts to Value Deals

It’s not just Denny’s tightening the belt. Applebee’s launched a “Whole Lotta Burger” meal for just $9.99, echoing a broader movement among restaurants to offer more for less. 

Nighttime exterior of an Applebee's restaurant, with its distinctive red and green neon signage and welcoming stone facade illuminated against the dark sky

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Everyone’s trying to keep the customers coming through the door.

Advertisement

Fast Food’s Competitive Edge

The fast food scene is heating up with deals like Chili’s $10.99 burger meal — a direct challenge to pricier options like the Big Mac. 

Close-up of a hand reaching for a Big Mac inside its box, with a McDonald's restaurant's characteristic interior decor in the background

Source: Annie Spratt/Unsplash

As the dining landscape evolves, affordability is becoming the key battleground.

Advertisement

Different Consumer Habits

It is getting harder and harder for eat-in restaurants to stay afloat.

A Deliveroo worker on a bike in a city center.

Source: Shopblocks/Wikimedia Commons

Since the pandemic, consumers prefer quick and convenient food over going to a diner. Nowadays, casual restaurants are less interested in restaurants and would rather have their food come directly to their homes.

Advertisement

Eat-In Diners Are Out

When it comes to convenient food, consumers want a wine-and-dine experience or a delivery to their homes.

A Denny's burger with two men eating their meals behind it.

Source: Miranda McDonald/Facebook

Dennis Gemberling, founder and principal of hospitality consultancy firm, Perry Group International, said “grab and go” food is taking center stage. This shift in consumer habits has left casual restaurants like Denny’s on shaky ground.

Advertisement

The End of Casual Dining

After the pandemic, customers started to go to casual diners on special occasions and got food delivered to their front doors for fast food.

A classic Denny's diner.

Source: Ben Schumin/Wikimedia Commons

Gemberling said: “I call it the demise of hospitality where everybody wants grab-and-go delivery. The whole market is starting to dwindle. Gone are the days of the Martini lunch.”

Advertisement