Space Crisis: NASA Astronauts ‘stranded’ by Malfunctioning Boeing Starliner, SpaceX Rescue in Talks

By: Georgia | Published: Jun 25, 2024

NASA has encountered a significant delay in the return of astronauts Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams from the International Space Station. 

Originally planned for a nine-day mission, their stay has been extended indefinitely due to malfunctions with the Boeing Starliner capsule. The complexity of the technical issues has prompted a thorough review before a new return date can be set.

Technical Challenges Identified in Boeing Starliner

The Boeing Starliner, tasked with returning NASA astronauts, has experienced critical malfunctions, including thruster failures and leaking valves. 

Advertisement
Detailed close-up view of the Boeing Starliner spacecraft orbiting Earth, showing the exterior and docking features

Source: NASA

These issues have compromised the spacecraft’s ability to function safely in space, leading to multiple postponements of the astronauts’ return to Earth, with a timeline now remaining uncertain as the review continues.

Advertisement

Potential Rescue Mission: SpaceX's Role Discussed

Experts are discussing the possibility of involving SpaceX to rescue the stranded astronauts by using one of its Dragon capsules. 

Advertisement
A SpaceX Falcon Heavy rocket illuminated by spotlights on a launch pad at night, ready for a mission with the moon visible in the background

Source: SpaceX/X

This option has become a topic of interest as NASA explores all possible solutions to ensure the safe return of the crew, demonstrating the growing reliance on commercial space entities in addressing spaceflight challenges.

Expert Analysis on Boeing's Predicament

Rudy Ridolfi, Former Space System Commander and Space Technology Acquisition Manager, explained the situation to the Daily Mail.

Advertisement
A cheerful group photo of international astronauts from various countries together inside the International Space Station

Source: NASA

He said, “Boeing will still want the capsule back. The service module is the part with all the problems and they will lose that on reentry no matter what they do. The capsule though, it can be returned, autonomously to a hard landing in the US and recovered.”

Alternate Spacecraft Consideration by NASA

According to Katsuo Kurabayashi, professor of aerospace engineering at New York University, “it is possible that NASA could decide to use an alternative spacecraft, like SpaceX’s Crew Dragon, to bring the astronauts home safely.” 

Advertisement
The SpaceX Crew Dragon spacecraft approaching the International Space Station for docking, set against the backdrop of space

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This highlights the flexibility NASA is maintaining in its approach to resolve the situation.

NASA and Boeing's Cautious Approach

Both NASA and Boeing are taking extensive precautions with the Starliner’s return missions. 

A Boeing Starliner capsule seen from a distance in space, approaching Earth with blue oceans and white clouds visible below

Source: NASA

They are committed to ensuring that the spacecraft is thoroughly prepared and certified for its journey back to Earth. This careful approach is aimed at preventing any further issues that could jeopardize the astronauts’ safety.

Advertisement

Revised Return Schedules and Ongoing Delays

The astronauts’ return was initially rescheduled from June 14 to June 26, reflecting ongoing uncertainties. 

Two astronauts in blue flight suits holding manuals and equipment, smiling at the camera in a spacecraft assembly or testing facility

Source: NASA

NASA is carefully evaluating potential return dates following planned space walks, aiming to secure a safe journey back to Earth for the astronauts by early July, depending on the resolution of the technical issues.

Advertisement

NASA’s Methodical Decision-Making Process

Steve Stich, manager of NASA’s Commercial Crew Program, has explained the decision process.

Two astronauts in blue flight suits and helmets inside a spacecraft simulator, focusing intently on control panels and manuals

Source: NASA

He said, “We are taking our time and following our standard mission management team process. We are letting the data drive our decision making relative to managing the small helium system leaks and thruster performance we observed during rendezvous and docking.”

Advertisement

Continuous Challenges from Launch to Docking

The Starliner faced obstacles right from its launch, which proceeded despite a known leak. This was followed by thruster failures that complicated its docking with the ISS. 

A male and a female astronaut smiling as they peer through the hatch of a spacecraft, in a close quarters setting inside a space module

Source: NASA

These ongoing issues reflect deeper challenges in the spacecraft’s design and functionality, which Boeing and NASA are working to understand and resolve.

Advertisement

Financial and Technical Stakes for Boeing

Boeing has incurred significant financial overruns, with costs escalating $1.5 billion beyond the initial $4.5-billion NASA contract. 

The Boeing Starliner spacecraft docked at a preparation facility with visible U.S. and Boeing logos

Source: Wikimedia Commons

These overruns coincide with the technical difficulties faced during the Starliner’s test missions, underscoring the high stakes involved in ensuring the spacecraft meets NASA’s safety and functionality standards.

Advertisement

Safety Concerns Amplify Scrutiny

Safety checks have been intensified following the technical mishaps with Starliner. Erin Faville, president of ValveTech, stressed the importance of safety, telling the Daily Mail, “I warned. I will choose to let it play out.” 

A group of five astronauts in blue NASA flight suits standing in front of the Boeing Starliner spacecraft at a space facility

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This statement reflects the heightened vigilance over the spacecraft’s performance amid ongoing technical setbacks.

Advertisement

SpaceX's Role in Future Missions

As the situation develops, SpaceX remains a potential player in ensuring the astronauts’ safe return. 

Former NASA Administrator Charles Bolden speaking to an audience in front of the SpaceX Crew Dragon capsule

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This collaboration could demonstrate the critical role of commercial spaceflight partners in supporting traditional space agencies during emergencies, showcasing an evolving landscape in space exploration logistics.

Advertisement